Super Lawyers
Consumer Attorneys California
AV Preeminent
State Bar of California
American Association for Justice

California Insurer Under Strong Scrutiny for Claim Denials

Aetna has had better weeks.

In fact, it’s likely that the country’s third largest insurer — and issuer of many health and long-term private disability policies to Californians — has never before endured criticism to the degree it now faces in the wake of recent news developments.

A deposition from late 2016 is at the core of what has rapidly become a company public-relations nightmare. It features taped comments from Dr. Jay Ken Iinuma, Aetna’s former medical director, over a multi-year span.

What Iinuma revealed has flatly shocked legions of providers, regulators and medical industry commentators across the country. He stated that he routinely denied care claims without ever consulting with doctors or even examining patients’ records. Moreover, he only checked with nurses offering opinions on approve-versus-deny matters, and “zero to one” times per month on average.

Iinuma’s comments have resonated across the country like a grenade blast. Prominent doctors, medical professors and others allege bad faith in Aetna claim denials underlain by a claim review process that is illusory, unlawful and potentially deadly for patients.

One prominent physician commenting on Iinuma’s statement that he never once even scanned a medical record in a case where he denied coverage calls that admission “incredible.” Another said he was “shocked” and “flabbergasted” by it.

Some painful reckoning may be on the way. The California insurance commissioner says that his department will now systematically peruse every Aetna claim that was denied during Iinuma’s tenure as medical director.

Experienced LTD attorneys who advocate solely and forcefully on behalf of policyholders note with interest — but not stark surprise — an insurer’s admission of what is clearly bad-faith conduct in the claim-denial process.

We make an additional point at the established LTD insurance law firm of Roboostoff & Kalkin in San Francisco concerning policyholders who are treated unlawfully by private insurers.

That is this: Such individuals have many rights that parties insured under ERISA-governed plans lack when seeking a meaningful legal remedy. Those include the right to a jury trial, the potential to receive additional damages for emotional distress, and in certain instances, punitive damages.

When you pay for a disability policy and dutifully comply with its terms, your insurer has a reciprocal duty to act in good faith. When it doesn’t, a proven legal team can advocate aggressively for you and seek maximum compensation on your claim.

Client Reviews
Just when I thought there was no hope to recover my LTD benefits, I found attorney Constantin Roboostoff. With his expertise, I was able to recover all of my back long term disability benefits. Other attorneys wouldn’t take my case because it wasn’t cut and dry. Mr. Roboostoff took the challenge and did an incredible job. Not only did he get my current disability benefits going, he also recovered all my back benefits. He was a true blessing and I would recommend him whole heartedly. CW
It was my pleasure to make contact with Scott Kalkin three years ago after other lawyers had turned me away and told me I would not succeed in my lawsuit. Thanks to Scott's thoroughness, dedication, and diligence, my lawsuit WAS successful and he saw me through to the end, which included putting legal pressure on the insurance company which had invested so much time, personnel, and money, in not paying me what was due. RB
As soon as I met with Scott, I could tell he was knowledgeable, resourceful, experienced, highly professional, and would be dedicated to getting me fair treatment. Scott has handled all interactions with my insurance company ever since. Being able to rely on him to represent me has been a huge relief for a chronically ill person. SO